- Listen to Matt discuss Defenseless Under the Night on the Diane Rehm Show
- Read Matt's recent article "Echoes of Donald Trump from Fiorello LaGuardia: How New York City's mayor fearmongered against the Japanese" in the New York Daily News
- Politics & Prose Bookstore reading and book-signing event for Defenseless Under the Night
Acclaim for Defenseless Under the Night
"Dallek's immensely readable Defenseless Under the Night...is a meticulous account of an epic battle that set Roosevelt, the first lady, against La Guardia, the mayor of New York, as the two created the country’s first Office of Civilian Defense (OCD), the precursor to what we know today as the Department of Homeland Security.... Dallek makes clear that the epic battle between them wasn’t without purpose: They ignited an important conversation about liberalism and its role in times of crisis. And while they never really found the perfect balance between civil liberties and national security, they made sure that people would discuss it for decades to come.”
-Dina Temple-Raston, The Washington Post
"Following sudden and unexpected assaults [on the United States], presidents of all ideological stripes typically call on the public not to be afraid. The tradition, as historian Matthew Dallek shows in a fascinating new book, 'Defenseless Under The Night: The Roosevelt Years and the Origins of Homeland Security,' goes back to the fear Americans felt in the 1930s."
"This is a great book. Rarely does a reader get to have the unique combination of fascinating history, contemporary relevance, drama, and intrigue all come together in wonk-policy detail while still being a work enjoyable to read. In some ways, the horror and aftermath of 9/11 made this book much more interesting than it would have been before that seismic event: very few would have guessed the origins of homeland security could be traced as far back as the 1930s and FDR. Nor would many realize what a prominent policy role the First Lady would have had back in that time period. The author takes us through all of the touch points that actually read like modern headlines in the New York Times: government propaganda, militarized civilian life, competing political visions for national defense, and the evolution of national security into the public consciousness. All of these things were the foundation of the myriad problems plaguing the Office of Civilian Defense under FDR in the 30s. This should make all readers wonder just how far the country has progressed and how far it still has to go."
-- CHOICE, a publication of the Association of College and Research Libraries
"Matthew Dallek's powerful history of America's wartime needs from civil defense to homeland security is urgently needed now. Deeply researched, vividly written, this splendid book highlights Eleanor Roosevelt's prescient l940 effort to launch a movement for civil defense, citizen empowerment, human rights-and the widespread opposition to those goals - which reflect our ongoing political divisions."
--Blanche Wiesen Cook, author of Eleanor Roosevelt
"Ever since 9/11, Americans have yearned for a return to an idyllic earlier time when no one in this country had to fear a rain of death from the sky. But in this fascinating book, Matthew Dallek reveals vividly that anxiety about terror from abroad began as early as 1938. He also gives readers a fresh appreciation of Eleanor Roosevelt, who viewed civil defense as an
opportunity for social advance - an emphasis that has been discarded in today's concern with 'homeland security.'"
--William E. Leuchtenburg, author of Franklin D. Roosevelt and the New Deal, 1932-1940
"Matthew Dallek's book represents political history at its very best. Informed by meticulous research, written in vivid prose, and full of shrewd insight, Defenseless Under the Night shows how the Roosevelt administration struggled to maintain the proper balance between protecting individual rights and ensuring the nation's security. It is an issue that is as relevant today as it was in the 1930s and 1940s."
--Steven Gillon, author of Pearl Harbor: FDR Leads the Nation into War
"An engaging and thoughtful portrait of the United States on the cusp of World War II. Dallek's book offers a gripping account of the little-studied civil defense program and its influence on American society. The conflicts among Dallek's rich main characters, including Eleanor Roosevelt and Fiorello LaGuardia, show that World War II was not just a fight against fascism abroad; it was also a struggle over the future of liberalism at home."”
--Beverly Gage, author of The Day Wall Street Exploded: A Story of America in Its First Age of Terror
"The fascinating story of the rise and fall of the Office of Civilian Defense (OCD), America's first federal office of homeland security…. Thoroughly explains how national leaders, including those at OCD, used fear to motivate Americans to prepare for war [and] will appeal to those interested in the World War II home front, civilian defense, or the FDR administration."
"A compelling look at the origins of national security...a timely history that resonates powerfully today."
-- History Book Club
"The fascinating history behind America’s first federal office of homeland security created by President Franklin D. Roosevelt."
-- New Books Network
In his 1933 inaugural address, Franklin D. Roosevelt declared that "the only thing we have to fear is fear itself." Yet even before Pearl Harbor, Americans feared foreign invasions, air attacks, biological weapons, and, conversely, the prospect of a dictatorship being established in the United States. To protect Americans from foreign and domestic threats, Roosevelt warned Americans that "the world has grown so small" and eventually established the precursor to the Department of Homeland Security - an Office of Civilian Defense (OCD). At its head, Roosevelt appointed New York Mayor Fiorello La Guardia; First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt became assistant director. Yet within a year, amid competing visions and clashing ideologies of wartime liberalism, a frustrated FDR pressured both to resign.
In Defenseless Under the Night, Matthew Dallek reveals the dramatic history behind America's first federal office of homeland security, tracing the debate about the origins of national vulnerability to the rise of fascist threats during the Roosevelt years. While La Guardia focused on preparing the country against foreign attack and militarizing the civilian population, Eleanor Roosevelt insisted that the OCD should primarily focus on establishing a wartime New Deal, what she and her allies called "social defense." Unable to reconcile their visions, both were forced to leave the OCD in 1942. Their replacement, James Landis, would go on to recruit over ten million volunteers to participate in civilian defense, ultimately creating one of the largest volunteer programs in World War II America.
Through the history of the OCD, Dallek examines constitutional questions about civil liberties, the role and power of government propaganda, the depth of militarization of civilian life, the quest for a wartime New Deal, and competing liberal visions for American national defense - questions that are still relevant today. The result is a gripping account of the origins of national security, which will interest anyone with a passion for modern American political history and the history of homeland defense.